Conversion and measurementGoogle Analytics alternatives

The best alternatives to Google Analytics

Matomo, Plausible, Piwik PRO, Fathom: Google Analytics alternatives compared on hosting, cookies, price and the nLPD rules.

Mehdi B.

Co-founder · SEO & digital strategy

The best alternatives to Google Analytics
In brief

The main alternatives to Google Analytics 4 are Matomo, Piwik PRO, Plausible, Fathom, Simple Analytics, Clicky and Mixpanel. For an SME in French-speaking Switzerland, we recommend Plausible or Matomo set up without cookies, and GA4 only if Google Ads carries a lot of weight. Cookieless does not mean obligation-free: Swiss law requires informing the visitor and letting them refuse.

The Google Analytics alternatives that hold up in 2026 are Matomo, Piwik PRO, Plausible, Fathom, Simple Analytics, Clicky and Mixpanel. All of them measure site traffic, but they do not play in the same category: some keep data in Europe and do without cookies, others are aimed at product teams or large organisations. The benchmark remains Google Analytics 4 (GA4), the only Google Analytics product still in service.

Our view, for an SME in French-speaking Switzerland, is fairly clear. A brochure website or a small shop does not need the full power of GA4, and gains in readability with a cookieless tool such as Plausible, or with Matomo installed on a server you control. GA4 keeps its place when Google Ads carries a significant share of your acquisition, because the two tools are designed to work together. One caveat applies to all of them: “cookieless” does not mean “obligation-free”, and Swiss law still requires informing the visitor and giving them the option to refuse.

Comparison table of Google Analytics alternatives

Prices are those displayed on each vendor's site in November 2026, in the vendor's currency, excluding taxes. A “hit” or an “action” corresponds to a page view, a tracked click or another recorded event.

Tool Data hosting Cookieless Free or self-hosted Public entry price
Google Analytics 4 Collection via servers in the United Kingdom, Switzerland or the EU for European visitors, then processing by Google No (cookies _ga, two years by default) Free Free
Matomo Cloud in Frankfurt (Germany); On-Premise version on the server of your choice, in Switzerland if you wish Option to enable Free On-Premise Community version Cloud from CHF 21.- per month for 50’000 hits (price displayed in francs)
Piwik PRO Business plan in an EU-operated cloud, in Sweden; Enterprise plans with a choice of data centre or private cloud Anonymous tracking mode for visitors who decline cookies 30-day trial, no free plan on the pricing page EUR 36 per month (Business)
Plausible European infrastructure for the cloud version; Community Edition on the server of your choice Yes, by default Free Community Edition (AGPL licence), 30-day trial USD 9 per month up to 10’000 page views
Fathom EU visitors anonymised in the EU, data then stored in the United States Yes, by default 7-day trial, no free plan or self-hosting USD 15 per month up to 100’000 page views
Simple Analytics EU, main infrastructure in the Netherlands Yes, by default Free plan for hobby sites (30 days of history, mandatory badge) EUR 20 per month per user
Clicky Location not stated on its public pages Yes, by default Free up to 3’000 page views per day (30 days of history) USD 9.99 per month (Pro)
Mixpanel United States or EU, chosen when the project is created No (cookie by default) Free up to 1 million events per month Usage-based billing beyond that

One name is deliberately missing: Gauges, still cited in many comparisons, no longer exists. Fathom acquired it on 15 April 2026 and the service closed on 30 April 2026.

Google Analytics 4: what it does, and why an SME looks elsewhere

Universal Analytics, the previous version, stopped processing data on 1 July 2023 for standard properties. Since the week of 1 July 2024, Google no longer provides access to either the interface or the API of these properties, and the company has announced the permanent deletion of their data. Looking for an alternative to “Google Analytics” today therefore amounts to looking for an alternative to GA4.

GA4 is free, comprehensive and connected to the rest of Google's ecosystem. Linked to a Google Ads account, it lets you create conversions from your key events, build remarketing audiences and display campaign data in its reports. For a company that invests in Google advertising every month, this link has real value: it makes it possible to run Google Ads campaigns on the enquiries actually received, and not on clicks alone.

The reasons to look elsewhere are nonetheless concrete. The first concerns cookies: by default, GA4 sets two cookies, _ga and _ga_<identifiant>, which last two years. The site therefore falls under Swiss cookie rules, and under European rules if it targets EU visitors.

The second reason concerns data sharing. In the sharing settings of an Analytics account, the “Google products and services” option allows Google to analyse your data and use it to improve its own products. Yet the FDPIC, the Swiss federal data protection authority, accepts the use of an external statistics tool provided that the vendor processes the data on behalf of the site operator, and not for its own purposes. We draw a simple rule from this: if you keep GA4, turn this sharing off.

The third reason concerns transfers to the United States. Google states that it complies with the Swiss-U.S. Data Privacy Framework, the framework recognised by the Federal Council on 14 August 2024 and in force since 15 September 2024. Since that date, personal data can be sent to a certified American company without additional safeguards. Google also states that, for visitors located in Switzerland, the EU and the United Kingdom, GA4 neither records nor stores individual IP addresses. The framework is therefore in place, but it only covers certified companies, and Google's page does not say where the data is processed once collected.

That leaves the question of retention. A standard GA4 property keeps detailed user-level and event-level data for two or fourteen months, depending on the chosen setting. Detailed explorations beyond fourteen months are therefore not possible. Add an interface designed for teams of analysts, and you can see why an SME that wants to follow five numbers every Monday morning ends up finding the tool too heavy.

nLPD and FDPIC: under what conditions a measurement tool can do without consent

The revised Federal Act on Data Protection, the nLPD, has been in force since 1 September 2023. For cookies, the FDPIC published a guide on cookies and similar technologies on 22 January 2025, updated on 6 October 2025. Reading it corrects a widespread idea, in both directions.

In Switzerland, a private company does not, as a general rule, need prior consent to measure the audience of its site. That does not mean it is free to do anything. Article 45c of the Telecommunications Act, in force since 1 April 2007, requires informing the visitor and allowing them to refuse cookies that are not essential to the operation of the site.

The conditions set by the FDPIC guide

The guide describes what must be in place for audience measurement to be justified by an overriding private interest, without consent:

  • Visible information and right to object. Refusal must be easy to find, from the first visit as well as on later ones, and be possible in a few clicks.
  • Cautious default settings. Until the visitor has been able to learn about the processing and object to it, the use of cookies is limited to the minimum necessary, in line with Article 7 of the LPD.
  • A purely statistical purpose. The guide refers to Article 31 of the LPD: data is anonymised as soon as possible, which generally means immediately for a website, and the results do not allow individuals to be identified.
  • A vendor that works for you alone. An external tool is suitable provided that its vendor processes the data solely on behalf of the site operator.
  • Anonymous first. The FDPIC writes that the interest in analysing visitor flows does not justify analysing personal data if anonymous information is enough.

Express consent becomes mandatory again in two cases: when the measurement involves sensitive data, on a health, political, trade union or religious site for example, and when it leads to high-risk profiling, for example advertising tracking that spans many sites for the benefit of third parties.

Visitors from the European Union

A site in Geneva or Vaud often receives visitors from neighbouring France. The FDPIC points out that the GDPR applies to a Swiss company that tracks the behaviour of people located in the EU, and that the European legislator was primarily targeting the tracking of internet users. Matomo, for its part, stresses that in most European countries, online privacy rules require consent even for cookieless JavaScript tracking, unless an exemption applies.

France provides for such an exemption. According to the CNIL, an audience measurement tool can do without consent if its purpose is limited to measurement on behalf of the site publisher, if it produces only anonymous statistics, if it does not cross-reference the data with other processing and does not follow people from one site to another. The CNIL also recommends informing visitors, limiting the lifespan of trackers to thirteen months and data retention to twenty-five months.

The slogan “no need for a cookie banner” that you read on vendors' sites must therefore be read with these conditions in mind. Fathom itself writes as much on its compliance page: the absence of cookies does not automatically place a site outside the rules on access to the device, and the need for consent depends on the technology, the purpose and the applicable law.

What each tool is worth for an SME

Matomo

Matomo suits you if you want detailed analysis while keeping control of your data. The On-Premise version, installed on your own server, is free in its Community edition, with no limit on users or hits; in return it requires technical skills and a server, which you can place in Switzerland. The cloud version hosts the data in Frankfurt. Matomo sets cookies by default, but a configuration line or a checkbox disables them. The Business cloud plan includes importing Google Analytics data, a tag manager, heatmaps, session recordings and A/B tests. This is our recommendation for an SME that wants detailed analysis without depending on Google.

Piwik PRO

Piwik PRO targets organisations with strict requirements, in healthcare, finance or the public sector. The Business plan combines analytics, a tag manager, a data activation module and a consent management platform, with hosting in Sweden. Its anonymous tracking mode keeps counting visitors who refuse cookies. The entry price and the number of modules make it, in our view, an oversized tool for a brochure website.

Plausible

Plausible takes the opposite bet: a single-page dashboard, without cookies. To count unique visitors, the tool calculates an identifier from the IP address and the browser, mixed with a random value that is renewed and deleted every 24 hours; neither the IP address nor the browser signature is stored. The vendor is an Estonian company and the cloud version runs on European infrastructure. The free Community Edition can be installed on your server, but it receives only two releases a year and includes neither funnels nor e-commerce revenue tracking. For an SME site, it answers the question “how many visitors, where do they come from, what did they do?” without detours.

Fathom

Fathom, a Canadian company, offers the same philosophy: no cookies, a simple dashboard, fifty sites included in the first plan. Traffic from European visitors goes through servers located in the EU, where the IP address is removed, then the anonymised data is stored on Fathom's main servers in the United States. The system is serious, but a company that wants its data to stay in Europe will prefer Plausible or Simple Analytics.

Simple Analytics

Simple Analytics is published from Amsterdam and hosts its data in the EU, mainly in the Netherlands. The tool works without cookies and without storing IP addresses. The free plan, reserved for hobby sites, deletes data after thirty days, which makes it unusable for a business. One caveat: the optional artificial intelligence assistant sends data to a provider located outside the EU, so it should only be enabled with full knowledge of that.

Clicky

Clicky works without a tracking cookie by default and applies, again by default, its privacy settings to all visitors, with heatmaps in the paid plans. Its site does not say where the data is hosted. For a Swiss company, this silence is enough for us to place it behind the European tools.

Mixpanel

Mixpanel does not replace GA4 on the same ground: it is a product analytics tool, which tracks events and journeys in an application or online service. It is of interest to a start-up that wants to know which features its users adopt. EU hosting must be chosen when the project is created, and the JavaScript script relies on a cookie, which places it under the same obligations as GA4.

Choosing your measurement tool: the approach we recommend

Take an accounting firm of ten people in Fribourg, with a brochure website, a contact form and a modest Google Ads campaign. Its real need comes down to four questions: how many visitors, through which channels, which pages, how many contact requests. Here is how we would proceed with them.

  1. Write down the questions before choosing the tool. If none concerns journeys within an application, Mixpanel drops off the list. If none calls for heatmaps, Plausible is enough.
  2. Look at where visitors come from. A notable share of EU visitors brings the GDPR and European cookie rules into the equation.
  3. Decide what to do with GA4. If Google Ads campaigns matter, GA4 can stay in place, carefully configured, alongside a cookieless tool that serves as the daily dashboard.
  4. Configure before publishing. Disable cookies where the tool allows it, turn off data sharing with the vendor, set the retention period and exclude internal visits.
  5. Update the privacy statement. It names the tool, the purpose, the hosting location and how to opt out, with a visible objection link in the footer. Our nLPD checklist for websites details the other technical points.
  6. Run both tools in parallel for a few weeks. The figures will not match, and that is normal: a cookieless tool counts visitors differently. What matters is to understand the gap before switching off the old tool.

Installing the script is the easy part. The real work lies in deciding what you want to measure, then sticking to it. If you would like to sort this out with us, start with the first conversation.

Sources

Mehdi B.
About the authorMehdi B.

Co-founder of Smart Impact. Hooked on the web from the start, he launched his first project in 2006: an online music magazine still running today. With close to 20 years of SEO experience, a Swiss federal diploma in marketing and a solid geek streak, he turns clients' ideas, sometimes hazy ones, into concrete digital projects with his team.

LinkedIn
Further reading