Digital transformationmicromanagement

Are you a micro-manager? 6 unmistakable signs of micro-management

The 6 signs of micro-management described by the Harvard Business Review, what Gallup and research on autonomy say about it, and how to move past it.

Mehdi B.

Co-founder · SEO & digital strategy

Are you a micro-manager? 6 unmistakable signs of micro-management
In brief

Micromanagement means applying the same level of control to every task, whether it deserves it or not. It shows in six signs, from deliverables that never satisfy to being copied on every e-mail. Our position, particularly in a website, CRM or automation project: set the expected outcome and a few indicators, then let the team choose the path.

One Tuesday evening, the head of a 15-person SME in Fribourg is reading through the texts of his future website for the third time. He asked to be copied on every exchange with the graphic designer, he rewrites the headings his marketing manager approved the day before, and he demands a progress update every morning. The project does not move any faster for it. His team, for its part, has stopped suggesting anything. This typical scenario has a name: micromanagement, that is, applying the same level of control to every task, whether or not it justifies it.

The Harvard Business Review has described six signs, and these are the ones we take up here, in order. Our reading is that of an agency that runs digital projects with SME leaders in French-speaking Switzerland. A website redesign, the arrival of a CRM or the automation of a process do require the boss to entrust part of the work to people who master it better than they do. In our view, these projects are steered by the expected outcome and by a few well-chosen indicators, not by monitoring every step.

Micromanagement: what exactly are we talking about?

Muriel Maignan Wilkins, an executive coach, published an article in the Harvard Business Review in November 2014 titled “Signs That You’re a Micromanager”. She acknowledges from the outset that attention to detail and concern for getting work done are part of a manager’s job. The problem with micromanagers, she writes, lies elsewhere: they apply the same intensity and scrutiny to every task, whether the situation requires it or not. She adds that most of them do not realise it.

The firm Gallup offers complementary insight in a guide on micromanagers, published in 2020 by Ben Wigert and Ryan Pendell. For its authors, micromanagement appears where there is no relationship of trust and support between a manager and an employee. They describe a manager who wants things done exactly their way, while giving little context, help or advice.

This guide also dismantles a received idea. The micromanager is not necessarily the one who talks to their team too often: Gallup notes that only 34% of the employees surveyed strongly agree that their manager knows what projects or tasks they are working on. In other words, nitpicking control coexists very well with a lack of dialogue on substance.

The stakes go beyond individual comfort. In an article by Jim Harter and Amy Adkins published in 2015, Gallup estimates that managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement scores. The style of the person leading therefore weighs heavily on how a team commits to a project.

The 6 signs of micromanagement according to the Harvard Business Review

Wilkins draws up a short, direct list. Each sign, taken alone, can pass for rigour. It is their accumulation, and their application to every task without distinction, that gives the micromanager away.

the micromanager in business

1. No deliverable ever quite satisfies you

The website mock-ups come back with a list of comments, the next version too, and the third again. Nothing is ever really wrong, but nothing is ever approved. In the end, the team understands that delivering is of little use since the leader will redo everything. Wilkins describes this mechanism under the name “learned helplessness”: employees end up believing they can only do good work if their manager supervises them closely. It is a vicious circle, since this dependence in turn justifies the control.

2. You would have done it differently, and it irritates you

Take the sales manager in charge of configuring the new CRM. They organise the sales stages their own way, and the leader would have split them differently. Yet nothing says the boss’s version would be better. Teresa Amabile put it as early as 1998 in the Harvard Business Review: creativity thrives when people are given autonomy over the means, not necessarily over the ends. Her image has endured: tell the team which mountain to climb, and let them decide how to climb it.

3. You hunt for details and correct everything

A comma in a welcome text, the shade of grey of a button, the order of two fields in a form. Wilkins notes that the micromanager takes a form of pride, or suffering, from their corrections. She quotes the feedback received by an executive she was coaching: he “gets too involved and becomes the bottleneck”. His colleagues added that he spent his time in the details instead of dealing with strategic issues. In a website project, the result shows quickly, because each minor correction pushes back a launch that is in itself valuable.

4. You want to know where everyone is at all times

The project tracking board, whether Trello, Asana or a simple shared spreadsheet, then becomes a surveillance tool rather than a coordination tool. The leader checks it several times a day and asks why a given card has not moved since yesterday. Yet research on autonomy at work points the other way. A study by the Business School of the University of Birmingham, published in 2017 in the journal Work and Occupations, used two years of data covering 20,000 employees from the British Understanding Society survey. It links a higher level of autonomy, particularly over tasks, pace and working hours, to better well-being and greater job satisfaction.

micro manager is it you?

5. You demand repeated progress updates

A misreading needs avoiding here. Gallup recommends that managers have a useful conversation with their employees every week, and its 2023 work shows that employees who received useful feedback the previous week are markedly more likely to be engaged. The problem therefore does not come from the weekly check-in. It comes from the daily chasing, with no specific purpose, which forces the team to produce reports instead of moving forward. Gallup also observes that engagement scores fall as efforts to hold people accountable multiply, and that micromanagement can create fear and paralysis rather than a sense of responsibility.

6. You insist on being copied on every e-mail

It is a discreet sign, which costs a lot in an automation project. If every exchange between the accountant and the integrator goes through the leader’s inbox, every decision waits for their green light. Among the symptoms of a micromanaged team, Gallup cites precisely the fact that every decision must be approved by the manager, and projects regularly blocked by too many meetings and validations. Wilkins points to a longer-term risk: an organisation becomes vulnerable when its team is no longer used to operating without the presence and heavy involvement of its manager.

The 6 signs in a table

Sign What the team takes from it Alternative
No deliverable satisfies Delivering is pointless, the boss will redo it Write down in advance what an acceptable deliverable is
Irritation at other people’s methods Only the boss’s way counts Set the outcome, ask the team how it plans to achieve it
Constant detail corrections Small things come before the goal Reserve your attention for the points that commit the company
Need to know where everyone is We are being watched, not supported Check progress at a fixed time, not continuously
Repeated progress updates Reporting takes more time than working A useful weekly check-in, with an agenda
Copied on all e-mails Nothing is decided without them Define what goes up to the leader, and the rest is settled without them

How to move away from micromanagement in a digital project

Wilkins suggests four approaches: face up to the excuses we give ourselves, let go in small steps, pass on the “what” rather than the “how”, and assume the team will succeed most of the time. We translate them here into the context of a website, CRM or automation project, because these projects raise the question of delegation in concrete terms.

Write down the expected outcome before starting the work

Wilkins speaks of “conditions of satisfaction”: the manager’s role is to describe what the end result looks like, without dictating each step to get there. For a website redesign, this often fits on one page. It covers the target audiences, the essential pages, the actions expected from visitors, the desired tone and the legal constraints. Once this document is approved, the discussion focuses on the gap between the delivery and what was agreed, and no longer on the taste of the moment.

Track a few indicators rather than watching everything

A leader who delegates does not give up control: they move it to indicators they check at fixed intervals. In a website project, this can be the milestones approved, the number of pages delivered against the plan and the acceptance-test feedback still open. For a CRM, the share of customer records updated and the opportunities with no dated next action say more than a daily reading of each record. In an automation, the number of runs in error and the tasks that remain manual are often enough to tell whether the tool keeps its promises.

Say clearly when you want to be consulted

Wilkins advises having an explicit discussion with employees about the level of detail we will go into, and about the cases where they should come to us. In practice, this amounts to setting an alert threshold: a budget overrun, a delay on a milestone, a choice that affects the brand or customer data. Below this threshold, the team decides on its own. Above it, it escalates the information without waiting for the weekly check-in.

Let go of one thing at a time and accept a few failures

Nobody moves from total control to trust in a week. Wilkins suggests starting with your own task list and identifying what can be handed over without risk, before going further. She also reminds us that the occasional failure is part of a solid record over time. Trust, for its part, is built in the relationship as much as in the tools, a point we develop in our article on emotional leadership in a digital transformation.

One word of caution to finish. Project management software does not cure micromanagement: in the wrong hands, it even makes it easier, since it allows you to see everything all the time. What matters is decided upstream, in what you look at and when. If you are preparing a website, a CRM or an automation and would like to set its indicators before delegating, we can talk about it in a first conversation.

Sources

micromanagementmanagementdelegationautonomy at workleadershipdigital project management
Mehdi B.
About the authorMehdi B.

Co-founder of Smart Impact. Hooked on the web from the start, he launched his first project in 2006: an online music magazine still running today. With close to 20 years of SEO experience, a Swiss federal diploma in marketing and a solid geek streak, he turns clients' ideas, sometimes hazy ones, into concrete digital projects with his team.

LinkedIn
Further reading