SEO and visibilitybad backlinks

Bad backlinks: how to identify and remove toxic links

Spotting bad backlinks, requesting their removal and knowing when Google's disavow tool is useful, according to the official documentation.

Mehdi B.

Co-founder · SEO & digital strategy

Bad backlinks: how to identify and remove toxic links
In brief

A bad backlink is an artificial link, off-topic or coming from a low-quality site. We advise spotting them with Search Console, third-party tools and a manual check, then asking for their removal at the source. Disavowing with Google is an advanced option, reserved for sites hit by a manual action for artificial links.

Do you think search optimisation is simply a question of volume? Think again.

In the world of SEO, backlinks are the currency. They act as votes of confidence from other sites towards yours.

But be careful: not all votes are equal.

Some “votes” can even cause problems. Let us reassure you first: since its December 2022 link spam update, Google says it uses its SpamBrain system to neutralise the effect of artificial links, and its documentation states that the disavow tool is of no use to the majority of sites. The serious risk concerns sites that have bought or manufactured links in quantity: there, a manual action can land.

This is the case in which a link profile contaminated by what are known as “bad backlinks” becomes a real issue.

Here is how to understand, identify and eliminate these toxic links in order to protect your digital investment.

To understand why bad links are dangerous, we first need to recall why links exist.

Google treats every link pointing to your site as a recommendation. If an authoritative site in your sector (such as a major Swiss media outlet or a government institution) links to you, your credibility rises sharply.

It is a strong signal for search engines. It indicates that your content is relevant, reliable and deserves to be highlighted.

A good link-building strategy aims for:

  • Better visibility on your strategic keywords.
  • An increase in qualified traffic.
  • Visitors who arrive with confidence, recommended by a site they already know.

The reverse is not symmetrical. A single dubious link is most often neutralised by Google; it is a profile built on artificial links that exposes the site.

A bad backlink is an artificial, irrelevant link, or one coming from a low-quality site, designed solely to manipulate search algorithms.

Thanks to its updates (such as Penguin or SpamBrain), Google has become extremely good at spotting these manipulation attempts.

If you have bought cheap link packages or worked with unscrupulous providers in the past, your site may be at risk.

Here is a checklist for spotting the bad kinds of links:

  • Blog comments: links generated automatically in comment sections are pure spam.
  • Forum profiles: Creating fake profiles on hundreds of forums just to slip a link into a signature is an obsolete and dangerous technique.
  • Footer links: having your link repeated on every page of a third-party site through the footer is a warning sign for Google.
  • Blogrolls: these lists of links, often in a blog's sidebar, no longer carry any SEO value and can be seen as artificial.

But that is not all. You also need to assess the source.

Here are the characteristics of the bad sites you really do not want links from:

  • Shared IP addresses: if dozens of sites linking to you are hosted on the same range of IP addresses, that is often the sign of a private blog network (PBN), set up to sell links.
  • “Spun” content: texts generated automatically or badly rewritten by software, often unreadable to a human.
  • Dubious sectors: If the site has inbound or outbound links to themes such as gambling, online pharma or adult content.
  • Geographic inconsistency: a company site based in Geneva receiving 70% of its links from China? That has no commercial logic and deserves a closer look.
  • Language inconsistency: in the same way, a site written in French receiving most of its backlinks from Russian or Chinese sites is suspicious.

Conversely, a good site is a site that does none of that. It has a genuine audience, clean editorial content and a topic close to your own.

Rows of empty seats with desks and voting devices in a parliamentary chamber, seen from above, each place as empty as a site penalised for bad backlinks.

How do you identify these toxic links?

You cannot fix what you do not measure.

For decision-makers and marketing managers, it is crucial to have a clear view of the health of your company’s link profile.

Here is how to go about a quick audit:

1. Use Google Search Console

It is Google’s free, official tool. In the “Links” section, you can see the “Top linking sites”. Go through that list. Do you see odd domain names, irrelevant country extensions (.ru, .cn, .tk) or sites with questionable content?

2. Use third-party analytics tools

Platforms such as Semrush, Ahrefs or Majestic let you list and sort the domains that point to you. Semrush goes further: its backlink audit gives each link a toxicity score from 0 to 100. A high score flags a link to examine, not necessarily a harmful one, and it is the vendor’s own indicator, not a Google rating.

3. Manual analysis (the final arbiter)

Tools do not do everything. Sometimes a link may look toxic algorithmically but be perfectly legitimate. Ask yourself this simple question: “If Google did not exist, would this link be of any interest to my business?” If the answer is no, it is probably a bad backlink.

The impact of these links is not trivial. They can lead to an algorithmic devaluation (your site slowly drops in the results) or a manual action (a Google employee decides to penalise your site). A manual action can target part of the site or the whole site, and it appears in the “Manual actions” report in Search Console. Once the links have been dealt with, it is from this same report that you request a reconsideration, describing the corrections made.

Once the culprits are identified, you have to act. Cleaning up links is a delicate process that calls for method.

Here are the two main steps for cleaning up your profile:

Step 1: Removal at source

This is the method most recommended by Google, but also the most tedious. It consists of contacting the webmasters of the sites hosting these toxic links to politely ask them to remove them.

Let us be realistic: the response rate is often low. Many of these sites are abandoned or run by bots. Documenting these attempts still matters, though, if you ever have to submit a reconsideration request to Google after a manual penalty.

Step 2: The Disavow Tool

If many artificial links remain online despite your requests, and they have led or risk leading to a manual action, you can ask Google to ignore them. This is known as disavowing.

Caution: this is an advanced feature, which Google reserves for sites targeted (or threatened) by a manual action for artificial links; for most sites, it is not useful. Using it badly can harm your performance. Only disavow links you are certain are toxic.

The procedure is as follows:

  1. Create a text file (.txt) encoded in UTF-8.
  2. List the domains to block using the format domain:le-site-toxique.com.
  3. Log in to the link disavow tool in Google Search Console.
  4. Select your property and upload the file.

By doing this, you are technically telling Google: “I have no control over these links, please do not take them into account when calculating my authority”.

It protects your site from the harmful effects of those links, without needing them to be physically removed from the web.

Protect your growth over the long term

SEO is not a sprint, it is a long-distance race that demands rigour and a strategic vision.

Shortcuts, such as building poor-quality links, always end up costing more than they bring in. Google penalties are severe and it can take months to recover.

For a company aiming for growth, quality must always take precedence over quantity.

Your objective should be to build a healthy digital ecosystem, based on strategic partnerships and high-value content that naturally attracts quality links. To frame this work on your link profile, discover our SEO support.

And if a manual action message has appeared in your Search Console, we can look at your link profile with you during a first conversation.

Sources

Mehdi B.
About the authorMehdi B.

Co-founder of Smart Impact. Hooked on the web from the start, he launched his first project in 2006: an online music magazine still running today. With close to 20 years of SEO experience, a Swiss federal diploma in marketing and a solid geek streak, he turns clients' ideas, sometimes hazy ones, into concrete digital projects with his team.

LinkedIn
Further reading