An SEO audit, in the minds of many executives, is a forty-page document with a high price tag. In practice, it is first of all a series of questions, asked in the right order. And for the first questions, free tools are more than enough. A free SEO audit of your site is therefore possible, provided you know which tool to question, and about what.
We use the following six tools every week, on our own sites as well as our clients'. The list itself is no secret. What changes everything is the order in which we make them talk, and then the precise question we ask each of them.
So we may as well give you the complete sequence, in order. The table below summarises it before the detail.
| Tool | Question it answers | Limit of the free version |
|---|---|---|
| Google Search Console | Does Google see my pages, and which queries do they appear for? | Free |
| PageSpeed Insights | What do my visitors experience, on mobile first? | Free, page by page |
| Screaming Frog | What does the crawler see when it goes through my site? | 500 URLs per crawl |
| Ubersuggest | What are people searching for in my line of business? | A few searches per day |
| Ahrefs Webmaster Tools | Who links to me, and what is deteriorating? | Verified sites only, 5’000 crawl credits per project per month |
| Google’s Rich Results Test | Is my structured data readable? | Free, page by page or code snippet |
A free SEO audit starts with a question, not with a tool
Before opening anything at all, define the problem. “My site does not bring me any enquiries” is not a diagnosis, it is a symptom. Behind it lie three possible causes, and they are not treated the same way.
Either Google does not see your pages. Or it sees them, but nobody searches for them or clicks. Or visitors arrive and leave without writing to you. Every tool in this list answers one of these three questions. That is why the order matters so much.
Google Search Console: the only source of truth
Everything starts here, because it is the only tool that shows real data rather than estimates. Google Search Console is free, official, and it tells you exactly which queries your pages appear for, how many people click, and at what position.
The most useful report for a company director fits into two columns: impressions and clicks. A page with many impressions and zero clicks is a shop window everyone walks past without going in. The problem is then not visibility, it is the title and the description shown on Google. The classic case: a page that racks up several thousand impressions in three months, ranks in position 35 or 40, and does not collect a single click. At that ranking depth, you simply do not exist. This kind of gap is spotted in ten minutes in the report, and it alone justifies setting up the tool.
The indexing tab deserves the same seriousness, incidentally. A services page that Google has not indexed does not exist for your prospects. If you were to configure only one tool this week, it would be that one. And if your site appears nowhere, the usual causes are well known, so it is worth checking them before suspecting the algorithm.
PageSpeed Insights: what your visitors actually experience
Second question: when someone arrives, what do they endure? PageSpeed Insights measures the speed and stability of your pages, on mobile first. Since Core Web Vitals, these measurements have been among Google’s official ranking criteria.
Three indicators are enough to form an opinion. LCP shows how long it takes for the main element of the page to display, and Google sets the bar at 2.5 seconds. INP, which replaced FID among the Core Web Vitals on 12 March 2024, measures the delay between a click or input and the page’s visible reaction: it should stay at 200 milliseconds or less. CLS measures whether the page moves during loading, which makes people miss clicks and annoys everyone, and Google wants it at 0.1 or less.
Test your five most important pages, not just the home page. On websites in French-speaking Switzerland, the culprit is almost always the same: beautiful photos that are far too heavy, uploaded as they are to look premium. A red score here means advertising budget leaking away, since every paid visitor lands on a page that drags.
Screaming Frog: the X-ray of your structure
Third question: what does Google’s robot see when it crawls your site? Screaming Frog is a piece of software you install that simulates exactly that pass. Its free version analyses up to 500 URLs, which covers the vast majority of SME sites.
It lists everything, coldly. Broken links leading to 404 errors. Redirect chains that waste crawler time. Orphan pages, the ones that exist but have no link pointing to them. Images with no alternative text.
The tool is austere, presenting its results in raw tables. It is also the most precise on this list for finding the technical error blocking an entire section of a site. Allow an hour to get to grips with it, and keep the export: it will serve as the point of comparison next time round.
Ubersuggest and Ahrefs Webmaster Tools: the playground
Then comes the question of the market: what are people looking for, and who captures those searches today?
Ubersuggest, Neil Patel’s tool, offers a few free searches a day. That is more than enough to check the essentials. Type in a query from your line of work, “accounting firm Lausanne” or “solar installer Valais”, and look at two figures: monthly volume and difficulty. A keyword nobody types is not worth an article. A keyword with high difficulty will take months of work, and that is strategic information in itself, not bad news really.
Ahrefs Webmaster Tools completes the picture, free of charge for sites whose ownership you can prove. Its historic strength is backlinks, in other words who links to you, and with what authority. Its audit can also be scheduled to revisit your site regularly, with an email alert when new problems appear. It is passive monitoring, and it is valuable: technical problems never announce their arrival. Regular monitoring helps avoid the nasty surprises you discover three months too late.
Google’s Rich Results Test: the quick check
The sixth tool plays a more modest role, that of a thermometer. Google’s Rich Results Test takes the address of a page, or a code snippet, and shows which rich results it detects there: reviews, FAQ, product listing, event. It also flags errors and suggestions on your structured data, and it tests the page as a smartphone by default.
Woorank used to fill this role in our list. Its browser extension has not been updated since December 2020 in the Firefox catalogue, and we do not recommend a tool that is no longer maintained. Google’s test does not give a score out of 100, but it serves the same purpose: checking a provider’s work in two minutes, or taking stock before a redesign.
One last point of method: write your starting figures down somewhere, even in a simple spreadsheet. An audit with no point of comparison measures nothing at all, and in six months you will be very glad to know where you started from.
Free SEO audit tool or audit by an agency: what sets them apart
A free SEO audit tool records what is wrong, page by page. It knows nothing about your market, your margins or your competitors, and it does not say in which order to act. An SEO audit carried out by a person starts from the same readings, then sorts them: what is really blocking, what can wait, what is not worth the effort.
In Geneva as elsewhere in French-speaking Switzerland, there are offers of a free website audit. Before asking for one, look at what it contains. An automatically generated report repeats the readings from the tools in this list, which you can produce yourself. An analysis carried out by a person takes time, and that time has a cost. For our part, the first conversation is free and serves to understand your situation. The full audit, however, is a piece of work: our Strategic SEO Diagnosis is a flat fee of CHF 1’490.-, delivered within 7 days, and the amount is credited if you continue with us on a retainer.
Frequently asked questions about SEO audits
Can you do a free SEO audit yourself?
For a first pass, yes. Search Console, PageSpeed Insights and the free version of Screaming Frog are enough to tell whether the problem is one of visibility, technical foundations or content. What takes experience is reading the results and deciding the order in which to tackle the work.
How much time should you allow?
Allow half a day for a first pass on an SME site. Ten minutes is enough to spot in Search Console the pages that are displayed without being clicked, an hour to get to grips with Screaming Frog, and the rest goes on testing your key pages and noting your baseline figures.
Do these tools work with WordPress?
Yes. They analyse pages as they are published, whatever tool builds them: WordPress, Wix, Shopify or a custom-built site. What changes from one system to another is how you fix what they find.
What is the best free SEO audit tool?
There is no single one. Search Console is the starting point, because it shows what Google actually sees of your site. PageSpeed Insights and the free version of Screaming Frog complete it for speed and structure.
What is a free SEO audit offered by an agency worth?
It all depends on what it contains. An automatically generated report flags technical errors, as the tools in this list do, without saying which ones matter for your business. An analysis carried out by a person takes time. At Smart Impact, the first conversation is free; the full audit is a flat fee of CHF 1’490.-, the Strategic SEO Diagnosis, delivered within 7 days.
What these six tools will not do
Let us be clear about the limits, because that is where misunderstandings become expensive.
These tools produce scores, alerts and tables. They do not produce decisions. Knowing that your LCP is 4.8 seconds does not tell you whether to change host, compress images or rebuild the theme. Knowing that a competitor is ahead of you on twenty queries does not tell you which ones bring in work and which ones only bring volume.
Interpretation, prioritising the work, budget arbitration: all of that remains a job in its own right. That is precisely what a proper SEO strategy covers, and it is also why a serious audit costs money: not for the figures, for the reading of them.
But the first pass, the one that answers the question “where is the problem”, is within your reach this week. Open Search Console, test your five key pages in PageSpeed, run a Screaming Frog crawl. With those three steps, you will already know whether your problem is one of visibility, technique or content. And if you would rather we made the diagnosis together, the first conversation is there for exactly that.
Sources
- web.dev: Core Web Vitals and their thresholds
- web.dev: INP becomes a Core Web Vital on 12 March 2024
- Screaming Frog: pricing and limits of the free version
- Ahrefs: Ahrefs Webmaster Tools, free plan for verified sites
- Ahrefs: site crawling in Ahrefs Webmaster Tools
- Google: the Rich Results Test
- Mozilla: WooRank extension page for Firefox




