SEO and visibilitySEO tools

SEO tools in 2026: how we choose between suites, specialist tools and in-house tools

Semrush at Adobe, Ahrefs pricing, Screaming Frog, home-made tools: Smart Impact's method for choosing SEO tools in 2026 without piling them up.

Mehdi B.

Co-founder · SEO & digital strategy

SEO tools in 2026: how we choose between suites, specialist tools and in-house tools
In brief

We pay for few SEO tools, each for a precise function: Ahrefs for links and competitors, Screaming Frog for the technical audit, Search Console for real data. Since Adobe's acquisition of Semrush, completed in April 2026, the large suites are aimed at major accounts. For a French-speaking Swiss SME, a specialised tool or a small in-house tool often meets the need better.

For us, choosing SEO tools comes down to asking a single question: which precise function will we use every week, and who does it best for the French-speaking Swiss market? The answer takes few subscriptions. We pay for Ahrefs for links and competitors, Screaming Frog for the technical audit, a few writing tools, and we read Search Console before anything else. When software is expensive and we only use one of its functions, we prefer to build it ourselves.

This is a deliberate stance, and we stand by it. The SEO tool market encourages accumulation: every month a new service promises to transform your SEO, and many companies end up paying for full suites only to open two screens. 2026 makes the question sharper, since Semrush now belongs to Adobe and the pricing of the two major suites has been reworked around paid add-ons.

The SEO tools we choose in 2026, in one table

Need Chosen tool Why
Inbound links and competitors Ahrefs A tool that has stayed focused on SEO, with a link index the vendor updates continuously
Technical audit Screaming Frog SEO Spider A finely configurable crawler, free up to 500 URLs
Real search data Google Search Console The queries that actually show your site, with no estimates
Semantic optimisation NeuronWriter Analysis of competing pages at a lower public price than Surfer
Text readability Yoast SEO Its readability checks, several of which work in French
Questions from internet users AnswerThePublic A quick view of the questions asked around a keyword
Task management monday.com A shared board rather than Excel files circulating by email
Dashboards Data Studio (formerly Looker Studio) Free, and connected directly to Search Console
Product pages, outreach In-house tools A specific function, built for our needs rather than rented

This table is not a ranking of the market. It describes an agency toolbox, built for French-speaking Swiss SME websites. If you are looking for a broader overview, our selection of the best SEO tools compares more solutions, category by category.

Why all-in-one SEO suites serve the French-speaking Swiss market poorly

The large suites were designed for high-volume markets, in English first. Their search volume estimates are statistical models: in a large market the error is diluted, whereas on a very specific query in French-speaking Switzerland it can become coarse. We regularly see a suite show zero volume for a query that generates impressions every week in the client's Search Console.

This is why Search Console remains our starting point. Its performance report, as Google's help explains, counts your site's clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position, query by query. It is not an estimate, it is what Google actually displayed. For an architecture firm in Neuchâtel or an accounting firm in Sion, a few dozen well-targeted searches often weigh more than the theoretical large volumes of a dashboard.

Then there is the question of languages. According to the Federal Statistical Office, French is the main language of around 23% of the population, far behind German and Swiss German. A company targeting the whole of Switzerland must therefore manage several language versions, and this is where general-purpose tools show their limits. Google's documentation on localised versions recalls a rule that is often misapplied: each version must declare, through the hreflang tag, both itself and all the others, failing which the annotations are ignored. Add to that a search intent that changes from one region to another (people do not look for health insurance in the same way in Geneva and in Zurich), and you understand why no automatic score replaces a human reading.

Semrush at Adobe: what the acquisition changes for SEO tools

Adobe announced the acquisition of Semrush on 19 November 2025, for 12 US dollars per share in cash, or about 1.9 billion US dollars according to the company's press release. The deal was completed on 28 April 2026. Adobe now presents Semrush as a source of visibility data, in search engines as well as in AI answers, intended to feed its customer experience offering for enterprises, alongside Adobe Experience Manager and Adobe LLM Optimizer.

This positioning says a lot. Semrush becomes a building block of a marketing suite for major accounts, and its pricing follows that logic. The public pricing page shows three main plans, SEO, Starter and Pro+, at 139, 199 and 299 US dollars per month on monthly billing (the vendor's public prices, in US dollars), slightly less with an annual commitment. Specialised toolkits, such as local SEO, content or traffic analysis, are bought separately according to Semrush's documentation. The local module, for example, is billed from 30 US dollars per location per month.

Our view has not changed, it has become sharper. Semrush remains a serious tool, but it is being built for marketing teams integrated into the Adobe ecosystem. For a French-speaking Swiss SME that wants to track its rankings, understand its competitors and fix its website, paying for a suite designed for multinationals often means funding functions it will never open.

Ahrefs or Semrush: why we keep Ahrefs, and at what price

Let us start with honesty: Ahrefs is not cheap, and it has also added paid options. The vendor's public pricing shows the Lite plan at 129 US dollars, Standard at 249 US dollars and Advanced at 449 US dollars per month, with up to 17% savings on annual billing (the vendor's public prices, in US dollars). Modules are added separately, such as the Content Kit from 99 US dollars, the Report Builder at 99 US dollars or traffic analysis at 99 US dollars. The entry price is therefore close to Semrush's.

What makes the difference for us lies elsewhere. First, Ahrefs remains focused on SEO, and its interface does not try to become a marketing command centre. Second, it is the link analysis that justifies the subscription: the vendor states a live link index updated every 15 to 30 minutes. In SEO, not seeing the links pointing to a competitor means working blind.

There is also a free way in that many business owners overlook. Ahrefs Free, formerly Ahrefs Webmaster Tools, gives access to a site audit that detects more than 170 technical issues and to a view of the keywords and links of your own site, provided you have verified it. For an SME just starting out, this is often enough before considering a subscription.

The specialised tools that earn their place

Screaming Frog for the technical audit

Screaming Frog SEO Spider remains our reference crawler for the technical audit. The free version is limited to 500 URLs, and the annual licence costs 199 pounds sterling at the vendor's public price. Many people use it only to spot pages returning a 404 error, whereas its strength lies elsewhere.

We configure the inclusion and exclusion rules, which work with regular expressions, so as to crawl only what matters. On an e-commerce site, we thus exclude cart, wishlist or admin pages, and filter parameters such as ?sort= or ?color=, which produce thousands of useless variants. The vendor's documentation points out a trap: the expression must match the entire URL, not just part of it. The URL rewriting option also makes it possible to remove tracking parameters without writing a single expression.

NeuronWriter and Yoast for content

For semantic optimisation, we use NeuronWriter, which analyses the top-ranking pages for a query and suggests the terms and questions to cover. On the two vendors' public pricing, its entry-level plan is clearly cheaper than Surfer's, and that is enough for us. We read its suggestions as leads, never as a checklist.

Yoast, the long-standing WordPress plugin, is useful to us mainly for its readability analysis, much more than for its green dots. According to Yoast's documentation, the free version checks sentence and paragraph length, passive voice and transition words, and the passive voice analysis is available in French. The Flesch score, however, is calculated only in English.

A robot bearing the Google logo holds a magnifying glass near a web browser window, suggesting a web search or an SEO website analysis in 2026.

AnswerThePublic, monday.com and Data Studio

AnswerThePublic helps us understand the intent behind a keyword, thanks to its presentation of the questions asked around a topic (who, what, where, how). One clarification is needed, however: the current pricing page now shows only paid plans, from 20 US dollars per month at the vendor's public price. It is no longer the small free tool you used to consult in passing.

For project management, we have dropped shared Excel files in favour of monday.com. Each SEO task, whether an audit, an article or a link-building effort, becomes a tracked item there, with its deadlines, and clients can see where their project stands.

As for dashboards, we prefer to build them ourselves rather than send the automatic PDF reports of the suites. Google's tool has been called Data Studio again since April 2026, after a few years under the name Looker Studio, and its basic version remains free according to Google Cloud's announcement. Its Search Console connector lets you track your pages' impressions and clicks, which can be cross-referenced with Google Analytics. These are the indicators we put forward, rather than authority scores invented by a vendor.

Custom SEO tools: AI fed by your own data

Our rule is simple. If a tool is expensive and we only use one function of it, we build that function ourselves. Coding assistants such as Cursor or Devin Desktop, the new name for Windsurf at Cognition, have made this choice realistic for an agency of our size.

These in-house tools are not used to have a machine write articles. Google states it clearly in its documentation on AI-generated content: AI can help with research and structuring, but mass-producing pages with no value for the user may breach its spam policies, and any generated content must be checked by hand. Our approach therefore starts from data. We give the model our Search Console exports, the structured data of competing pages collected by our own scripts, and the language rules specific to the Swiss market. The machine assembles, a human decides and proofreads.

The first example is a product page writer, an interface built in React and connected to the OpenAI API and to the catalogue data. It reads a product sheet, extracts the technical attributes (dimensions, material, features), then suggests a description specific to each item, in the brand's tone. For shops with thousands of products, this avoids the duplicate descriptions that standard plugins produce.

The second concerns outreach for link building. Platforms such as lemlist do this job very well, but their price climbs with volume, and their personalisation fields remain those of the software. Our own sending scripts connect directly to our contact databases and let us write messages that are truly tailored to each recipient, which matters in a French-speaking Swiss market where many people know each other.

An in-house tool nevertheless has a cost that is easily forgotten: it has to be maintained. An API changes, a model is withdrawn, and the tool stops working. This is why we only build narrow functions that are easy to take over, and never a full suite.

Choosing your SEO tools: the framework we apply

Take an accounting firm of ten people in Fribourg, with a brochure website of about thirty pages. Before any subscription, we would advise it to install Search Console and check it every month. It will see the queries that already show its site, those where it appears on the second page, and the pages that receive no impressions.

Free tools come next: the free version of Screaming Frog is enough for a site of this size, and Ahrefs Free gives a first view of its links and technical issues. Only when it comes to tracking specific competitors or launching a link-building effort is a paid subscription justified. Even then, a month of Ahrefs or Semrush, targeted at a single analysis, costs less than a year of a subscription that no one opens any more.

For each tool under consideration, we ask the same questions. Which function will you use every week, and does Search Console already answer it? Does a free version cover your page volume? Who in the company will actually open the tool? If nobody can answer the last one, the subscription is surplus.

This is the discipline we apply in our SEO support: few tools, each chosen for one task, and time spent on the site rather than on dashboards. A tool does not do your SEO for you; it only informs decisions. If you want to know which ones deserve your budget, let’s talk during a first conversation.

Sources

SEOSEO toolsdigital tools
Mehdi B.
About the authorMehdi B.

Co-founder of Smart Impact. Hooked on the web from the start, he launched his first project in 2006: an online music magazine still running today. With close to 20 years of SEO experience, a Swiss federal diploma in marketing and a solid geek streak, he turns clients' ideas, sometimes hazy ones, into concrete digital projects with his team.

LinkedIn
Further reading